Times Square: bright lights, bigger crowds, and… mediocre food? That’s the reputation that often precedes the iconic New York landmark. The sheer sensory overload of flashing billboards, costumed characters, and throngs of people can easily overshadow any culinary aspirations. Many visitors resign themselves to overpriced chain restaurants and generic fast food, believing that a decent meal in Times Square is a myth. But believe it or not, hidden culinary gems do exist.
Navigating the Times Square food scene can feel like traversing a culinary minefield. The high rents and constant flow of tourists incentivize some establishments to prioritize volume over quality. However, with a little insider knowledge, it’s entirely possible to find delicious and satisfying meals that won’t break the bank or leave you feeling disappointed. Forget the tourist traps – this guide will uncover the best-kept culinary secrets of Times Square, from authentic international cuisine to innovative takes on classic dishes. Times Square offers a variety of dining options that cater to diverse tastes and budgets, ranging from quick bites to upscale experiences, if you know where to look.
Quick and Casual Bites: Fueling Up on the Go
When you’re battling the crowds, racing to a Broadway show, or simply need a quick energy boost, a fast and satisfying bite is essential. Time is of the essence, and sacrificing quality for speed is not an option. Here are a few go-to spots for delicious and convenient meals that won’t keep you chained to a table.
Schnipper’s Quality Kitchen
This modern diner offers elevated comfort food classics in a bright and airy setting. Think juicy burgers, crispy chicken sandwiches, and loaded fries that are a step above the typical fast-food fare. Schnipper’s understands that a quick bite shouldn’t mean compromising on quality ingredients.
Must-try: The Sloppy Joe. Forget the canned sauce of your childhood – Schnipper’s version is made with slow-cooked beef, a tangy tomato sauce, and a toasted bun that will make you feel like you won the lottery. Open late, Schnipper’s Quality Kitchen is great for families and individuals who want good food quickly and efficiently. This is truly some of the best food in Times Square.
Los Tacos No. 1
Escape the New York chill or quench your thirst in the summer heat with authentic Mexican street food. This West Coast import has quickly become a favorite for its flavorful and authentic tacos, quesadillas, and mulas. The ingredients are fresh, the tortillas are handmade, and the prices are unbelievably reasonable for the location.
Must-try: The Adobada taco. Marinated pork is cooked on a vertical spit and shaved directly onto a warm tortilla. With onions, cilantro, and a squeeze of lime, it is a flavor explosion in every bite. Los Tacos No. offers simple, yet delicious, quick food.
Luke’s Lobster
Craving a taste of New England? Luke’s Lobster brings the freshest seafood rolls to Times Square. Their commitment to sustainable sourcing and simple preparations lets the quality of the ingredients shine. While slightly pricier than the other quick options, the lobster rolls are a worthwhile indulgence.
Must-try: The Lobster Roll. Chunks of sweet Maine lobster meat are tossed in lemon butter and served on a griddle-toasted bun. It’s pure, unadulterated lobster perfection.
Hidden Gems: Unexpected Culinary Delights
For those seeking a more distinctive and memorable dining experience, Times Square has a surprisingly diverse collection of hidden gems. These restaurants offer something beyond the typical tourist fare, whether it’s authentic ethnic cuisine or a unique and innovative menu. Step off the beaten path and discover these unexpected culinary delights.
Pure Thai Cookhouse
Nestled above the bustling streets, this unassuming Thai restaurant serves up some of the most authentic and flavorful Thai food in the city. Don’t let the simple decor fool you – the food is the star of the show here. The menu features regional specialties and dishes that you won’t find at your average Thai takeout joint.
Must-try: The Kuay Teow Reua (Boat Noodles). This rich and complex soup features rice noodles, tender pork, dark blood broth, and a medley of Thai herbs and spices. Reservations are highly recommended, as this place fills up quickly. It’s a great place for individuals who want to try a wide variety of interesting foods.
Joe Allen
A Theater District institution, Joe Allen has been serving up classic American comfort food and celebrity sightings for over fifty years. The walls are lined with posters of Broadway flops (a tradition started when the owner couldn’t afford to frame hit shows), creating a unique and convivial atmosphere.
Must-try: The Joe Allen Burger. A simple yet satisfying burger made with high-quality beef, served on a toasted bun with all the fixings. It’s a classic for a reason.
Havana Central
Transport yourself to Cuba with vibrant atmosphere and delicious authentic dishes at Havana Central. Located in the heart of Times Square, this restaurant offers a lively escape with live music, strong cocktails, and traditional Cuban cuisine.
Must-try: The Ropa Vieja. Slow-braised shredded beef in a flavorful tomato sauce, served with rice, beans, and sweet plantains. This is Cuba on a plate. Perfect for groups and a fun night out!
Sit-Down Restaurants: Ambiance and Experience
Sometimes, you need a break from the hustle and bustle of Times Square and crave a more leisurely and immersive dining experience. These sit-down restaurants offer a chance to relax, unwind, and savor delicious food in a comfortable and stylish setting. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply want to treat yourself, these restaurants provide an escape from the chaos outside.
Carmine’s
An Italian-American institution, Carmine’s is known for its family-style portions and lively atmosphere. Prepare to share, as the dishes are designed for groups. The food is classic Italian-American comfort food, prepared with fresh ingredients and served with generous portions.
Must-try: The Chicken Parmigiana. A massive breaded chicken cutlet topped with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese, served with a side of pasta. Be sure to bring a large appetite and a few friends.
Le Rivage
Offering classic French cuisine, Le Rivage has a cozy bistro feel that will make you forget you are in the middle of a bustling city. Using recipes handed down through generations, you’re guaranteed to find classic flavors here.
Must-try: The Crème brûlée. What’s a French bistro without a bit of perfectly sweet, perfectly creamy dessert? This menu item is a hit for a reason.
Dos Caminos
Craving a margarita and some upscale Mexican fare? Dos Caminos offers a vibrant and stylish setting for enjoying modern Mexican cuisine. From fresh guacamole to flavorful tacos to creative enchiladas, the menu has something for everyone. The cocktails are equally impressive, with a wide selection of tequilas and mezcals.
Must-try: The Grilled Fish Tacos. Fresh grilled fish is served on warm tortillas with a variety of toppings, including pico de gallo, avocado crema, and pickled onions. Enjoy the vibrant atmosphere!
Best Desserts in Times Square
No culinary adventure is complete without satisfying your sweet tooth, and Times Square offers a tempting array of dessert destinations. From decadent ice cream to artisanal pastries, there’s something to please every palate. Give in to your cravings and indulge in these sweet treats.
Junior’s Restaurant
Famous for its cheesecake, Junior’s is a Times Square institution. Sink your teeth into a slice of their classic New York cheesecake, or try one of their many other decadent desserts.
Must-try: The New York Cheesecake. It’s creamy, rich, and utterly irresistible. Junior’s Restaurant is a must-visit for dessert lovers.
Carlo’s Bakery
Made famous by the reality show “Cake Boss,” Carlo’s Bakery is a destination for elaborate cakes, pastries, and other sweet treats.
Must-try: The Cannoli. These crispy pastry shells are filled with sweet ricotta cream and chocolate chips. It’s an Italian staple for good reason. Carlo’s Bakery is a great place for social media photos, too!
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
An Artisanal ice cream shop, Van Leeuwen has unique and traditional flavors with a focus on quality ingredients.
Must-try: The Honeycomb ice cream. With a perfect balance of sweet and creamy, you can’t go wrong with this flavor.
Tips for Navigating the Times Square Food Scene
To make the most of your culinary experience in Times Square, keep these tips in mind:
- Reservations are Your Friend: Especially for sit-down restaurants, booking a reservation in advance is highly recommended, particularly during peak tourist seasons.
- Read Reviews: Before committing to a restaurant, take a few minutes to read online reviews to get a sense of the food quality, service, and atmosphere.
- Venture Off the Main Drag: The restaurants located directly on Times Square are often the most overpriced and crowded. Exploring the side streets and nearby blocks can lead to better deals and more authentic experiences.
- Seek Out Happy Hour Deals: Many bars and restaurants in Times Square offer happy hour specials with discounted drinks and appetizers. This is a great way to save money and sample different establishments.
- Lunchtime Savings: Consider dining during lunch, as many restaurants offer lunch specials that are more affordable than their dinner menus.
Conclusion: A Delicious Surprise Awaits
Don’t let the reputation of Times Square fool you – with a little planning and research, it’s entirely possible to find fantastic food that goes beyond the tourist traps. From quick and casual bites to upscale dining experiences, Times Square offers a surprisingly diverse culinary landscape that caters to a range of tastes and budgets. Explore the restaurants mentioned in this guide, discover your own hidden gems, and embrace the adventure. Next time you’re in Times Square, don’t settle for the ordinary. Embrace the adventure and discover the delicious surprises that await! You might just find your new favorite meal in the most unexpected place.
